> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.hwaelmag.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Small Hours: Robert Smith's Island Ear
- URL: https://www.hwaelmag.com/small-hours-robert-smiths-island-ear/
- Published: 2026-11-15T16:33:13.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-15T17:42:39.000Z
- Description: John Martyn and Nick Drake behind the Cure’s Seventeen Seconds.
- Author: Hwael Mag
- Tags: Essays, 2026, Post-Punk

### Late in 1977 an eighteen-year-old in Crawley taped John Peel's show and, the next day, played one John Martyn track over and over until he had saved the price of the album. Two winters later he went into a converted church in Willesden to make the first record he would call truly the Cure's.

---

*Seventeen Seconds* has a settled family tree. Critics trace it to Bowie's *Low*, which Smith says changed how he heard sound, to Siouxsie and the Banshees, whose stand-in guitarist he had just been, and forward to the grey city that the word "goth" would soon claim. The tree is accurate and incomplete. Smith himself named five records he played at his parents' house while writing the album, and one of them was Nick Drake's *Five Leaves Left*. He never put John Martyn on that list. He did, more than thirty years later, tell the story of how Martyn's *One World* entered his life, and that story places a rural, nocturnal record at the root of an album always heard as urban: a lake in Berkshire, recorded between three and six in the morning.

### I. The peel tape

Smith listened the way most people his age did. He taped Peel's Radio 1 show, as he said everyone did, played the tape back the following day, and kept returning to the same Martyn track until he had saved enough to buy the vinyl. In the sleeve notes he wrote for a 2011 tribute album, he dates the moment to late 1977 and names "Small Hours" as the song he fell for, adding that *One World* very quickly became his favourite of Martyn's records. In an interview from the same year he names the title track instead. The two accounts disagree on the song and agree on everything else, and the disagreement matters less than it seems: "One World" and "Small Hours" were the two pieces the engineer of the sessions remembered as the best work of the night shift.

*One World* came out on Island on 4 November 1977\. Chris Blackwell, the label's founder, produced it himself at Woolwich Green Farm, his house near Theale, after Martyn had spent a long break in Jamaica and come back with an ear for dub and for Lee Perry's studio. That combination, folk guitar run through effects pedals and laid over a drum machine, beside water, at night, reached a teenager in Crawley through a taped radio show.

### II. A house in a gravel pit

Phill Brown, who engineered the album, left a precise account. The house stood almost entirely surrounded by a flooded, disused gravel pit, a lake with a building in the middle. On 16 July 1977 the Island mobile studio was parked in the courtyard. Brown pointed a hired PA across the water from beyond the stables, set two Neumann microphones on the far side of the house to catch the guitar coming back off the lake, and pushed two more to the water's edge, as far as the cables would reach. Those picked up lapping water, birds, animals moving in the dark and a distant, strangled version of Martyn's guitar. Dew kept knocking the microphones out; they were swapped, dried and put back.

The working day ran from about two in the afternoon to five in the morning, with reels changed every half hour. Brown names the stretch from three to six as the hardest on the equipment and the most productive for the music: the title track and "Small Hours" both came out of it, each played for hours and then edited into shape. "Small Hours" closes the album at almost nine minutes, Martyn's echo-laden guitar over a drum machine he was mocked for bringing on stage, with Canada geese from the lake somewhere in the mix.

What Brown built was a room that included a landscape. The guitar is heard twice, once at the amplifier and once after it has crossed open water, and the second hearing carries the place with it. The prehistory of ambient folk turns on moments like this one, when the setting of a recording stopped being a neutral room and became part of the instrument. *One World*is among the clearest early cases, and Smith had saved up to own it.

### III. A church in Willesden

In January 1980 the Cure went into Morgan Studio One in Willesden with the money from their first album. Smith had bought ten days and used eight. Lol Tolhurst, in his memoir, describes the room as a former church, a new ceiling fitted under the old stained-glass roof, so that when the lights were off the glass showed through with a faint, ghostly glow. The band slept on the studio floor and worked sixteen or seventeen hours a day. Mike Hedges, co-producing with Smith, later said the record was so introspective that it wore all of them down. Smith's stated aim was a hybrid of his five records, with as few instruments as each song could bear.

Andrew Douglas photographed the band for the sleeve at around eight on the morning the recording finished, and Smith chose the out-of-focus frames over the sharp ones. The cover of *Seventeen Seconds* is a picture taken at the end of the work, in the grey light that follows Brown's hardest hours.

The kinship with *One World* is one of method. Both records were made through the night in a building with a past, and both treat the space around the sound as part of the composition, trusting repetition and silence to carry a song. The direction differs. Blackwell and Brown sent Martyn's guitar outward, across water, and let the countryside answer. Smith and Hedges kept everything indoors: flat drums, heavy compression, instrumentals such as "A Reflection" and "The Final Sound" that leave the room audible around a few notes. *Seventeen Seconds* sounds like *One World* turned inward, the lake drained and the emptiness kept.

The other Island thread points the same way. Smith first heard Nick Drake's "Time Has Told Me" on *Nice Enough to Eat*, a budget sampler Island issued in November 1969, when he was ten, and the song stayed with him for life. Its chorus offers a lover as the cure for a troubled mind, and whether that word named the band depends on whose account you follow. Tolhurst's memoir gives the band's own story: early in 1977 they cut their lyrics into strips, drew one from a hat and came out with "Easy Cure", the title of a song Lol had written. In 1978 Smith dropped the first word, which he thought too American and too hippyish. Decades later, talking to the BBC about his favourite music, Smith said that Drake's song had given him the idea for the name of the group. The two accounts can stand together, a word drawn by chance and then cut down by a singer who already had Drake's line in his ear, and nothing on record settles which came first.

Smith repaid the debt in public. Through the 1980s and 1990s the Cure brought "Time Has Told Me" into their live sets, and when MTV invited them to record an Unplugged session they chose to include it, which for many of their listeners was a first hearing of Drake. The boy who met the song on a sampler became, for a later audience, the sampler.

Drake and Martyn were friends and labelmates, and Martyn's "Solid Air" was written for Drake. The folk that reached Smith, then, came almost entirely through one label and one sensibility: quiet, close-miked, nocturnal, willing to leave room in a song.

### IV. Why nobody heard it

The omission has plain causes. Smith never listed *One World* among the records behind *Seventeen Seconds*, so no document requires the link. By 1980 Martyn belonged, in the press's eyes, to the generation that punk had been meant to clear away, and the Cure were being filed beside Joy Division and the Banshees. A reviewer of the 2011 tribute wondered in passing whether Martyn might lie behind the Cure's moodier sound, and the thought went no further.

The claim needs its limits stated. No source says that *One World* shaped a particular song on *Seventeen Seconds*. What is documented is Smith's devotion to the album from late 1977, the two years between that tape and the Morgan sessions, the night work on both records and their shared reliance on space. The memory itself was told in 2011, and a memory of 1977 told thirty-four years on deserves some caution. What this essay proposes is a genealogy of listening: an ear trained by Island's folk, applied to a record the press heard as the opposite of folk.

The 2011 cover shows the same ear at work. Asked to record "Small Hours" for the tribute, Smith went first to YouTube to watch Martyn play it, knew the chords and could not work out the fingering, which depends on Martyn's open tunings and chord shapes. The version he delivered is electronic. Thirty-four years after the Peel tape, the guitar part was still out of his reach and the night in it was not, much as *Seventeen Seconds* had kept the night and left the guitar style behind in 1980.

LISTENING NOTES / 01 

01 02 03 04 05 06 07 

John Martyn, “Small Hours” (*One World*, 1977)

The closing piece, recorded before dawn, with the lake in the microphones and a drum machine keeping time under the echo. 

John Martyn, “One World” (*One World*, 1977)

The other master from the night shift, and the track Smith remembers playing back from his Peel tape. 

Nick Drake, “Time Has Told Me” (*Five Leaves Left*, 1969)

The song Smith met on an Island sampler at ten, quiet and close, where his folk listening begins. 

The Cure, “A Reflection” (*Seventeen Seconds*, 1980)

The album opens without a voice, leaving the room to speak first. 

The Cure, “At Night” (*Seventeen Seconds*, 1980)

Smith tied it to a Kafka story about a guardian who stays awake; the album's own small-hours song. 

The Cure, “The Final Sound” (*Seventeen Seconds*, 1980)

Fifty-two seconds, stopped when the tape ran out, a sketch left in the shape the session gave it. 

Robert Smith, “Small Hours” (*Johnny Boy Would Love This*, 2011)

The cover, Martyn's night piece rebuilt with electronics by a player who could not copy the fingering. 

---

Last revised: November 2026

---